The Catalogue Raisonné: Research and Expertise

1st digital catalogue raisonné

This catalogue raisonné presents nearly 1700 paintings and pastels by Degas, enriched with 3300 exhibitions listed since 1865, with a rigorous scientific approach and the latest discoveries.

This catalogue builds upon previous works and publications, the four Degas sales of 1918-1919 (classified by paintings, pastels, and drawings), Paul-André Lemoisne's 1946 catalogue, and Philippe Brame and Theodore Reff's 1984 supplement.
The corpus of paintings and pastels presented here will ultimately include approximately 1700 works from public and private collections. Each is presented with its photograph, technical information, history, exhibitions, and bibliography, which holds an essential place here. For public collections, each work links to the museum to which it belongs. As for exhibitions where Degas displayed one or more works, we have counted 3300 from 1865 to the present day.

The immense contribution of Philippe Brame and Theodore Reff to the knowledge of Degas must be highlighted here, as well as that of other Degas specialists: Jean Adhémar, Jean S. Boggs, Richard Brettell, Lillian Browse, Françoise Cachin, Ann Dumas, Douglas Druick, Richard Kendall, Henri Loyrette, Anne Pingeot, Anne Roquebert, George Shackelford, Barbara Shapiro, Richard Thomson and Gary Tinterow.
Regarding Philippe Brame and Theodore Reff's 1984 supplement, we include some works with additional information after that date. We clearly mark by [BR] their contributions before 1984, thus recognizing their authorship of information.

The choice of digital

The immense contribution of Philippe Brame and Theodore Reff to the knowledge of Degas must be emphasized here, as well as that of other Degas specialists: Jean Adhémar, Jean S. Boggs, Richard Brettell, Lillian Browse, Françoise Cachin, Ann Dumas, Douglas Druick, Richard Kendall, Henri Loyrette, Anne Pingeot, Anne Roquebert, George Shackelford, Barbara Shapiro, Richard Thomson, and Gary Tinterow.
Regarding Philippe Brame and Theodore Reff's 1984 supplement, we reproduce certain works with complementary information after this date. We clearly mark their pre-1984 contributions with [BR], acknowledging the paternity of their information.

The Digital Choice

National Institute of Art History - Paris. Photo: M.S

Several reasons determined the choice of digital format, namely:
- The considerable amount of information existing on Degas's work, regarding both exhibitions and publications;
- The essential need to enrich and update Paul-André Lemoisne's 1946 catalogue raisonné of Edgar Degas;
- The efficiency, speed of dissemination, and flexibility of such a working method, overcoming a major obstacle of paper publication;
- Deletions, corrections, and modifications now possible with digital technology. For a catalogue raisonné, this is an essential mark of its vitality, relevance, and an obvious asset for its longevity.
- In our work records, we nevertheless leave the door open to other suggestions and dating proposals, which gives meaning to the critical catalogue.

In the work files, exhibitions and bibliographic elements are presented in abbreviated form. Complete information appears in the exhibitions and bibliography lists.

Degas in Numbers in Public and Private Collections

- In worldwide public collections: 49% of the total corpus. The United States leads with 24%, followed by France with 8%, predominantly in the Musée d'Orsay. Next are the United Kingdom, Switzerland, Germany, and Japan.
- In private collections: 22% of the total corpus.
- We also deliberately publish approximately 200 works not located by Lemoisne that remain unlocated.

The Selected Themes

A classification never before done: 8 themes represent the essence of Degas's work through his paintings and pastels: Dancers (35%); bathers (19%); portraits (25%); equestrian scenes (7%); music (2%); landscapes (7%); working women (2%); others (3%).
The digital catalogue's search engine now allows access to all this data and enables cross-referencing by themes, dates, supports, dimensions, techniques, signatures, and stamps.

The Main Techniques Used

- Pastels top the list of Degas's works with 1163 pieces, approximately 68%, mainly between 1880 and 1900.
- Oil paintings with 533 works, or 31%, including about 300 between 1870 and 1890.
The complexity of technical mixtures often attempted by Degas makes counting them sometimes difficult to report. Examples include pastels enhanced with charcoal or pastels on monotype that we wanted to publish here. In our eyes, these are the most beautiful and seductive works of the artist.

The Supports Used

We knew that Degas favored working on paper, whose technical benefits (speed of execution, drying) he began to appreciate, but also the financial interest, especially in the British art market. Contrary to what has sometimes been read, he did not abandon painting after the major shift in the mid-1870s. Undoubtedly, he then experienced more difficulty painting and consequently fulfilling commissions. Pastel and paper better corresponded to the problems he encountered, including the onset of blindness, which was not the least of his challenges. Leading the supports:
- Paper: 936 works, or 55%;
- Canvases: 471 works, or 28%;
- Cardboards: 56 works, or 3%;
- Tracing paper: 57 works, or 3%;
- Panels: 61 works, or 4%.
Results that highlight Degas's growing interest in varied and innovative pictorial experiments.

Between Stamps and Signatures: Other Revelations

Degas Sale Stamp

In the corpus of paintings and pastels we have established, it appears that:
- Nearly 707 works are signed;
- More than 684 have only the posthumous sales stamp;
- More than 335 bear neither signature nor stamp.

Related Works

Related works will be added later. See example MS-748.

What Our Dating Confirms

Through the digital critical catalogue, it appears that Degas was clearly most active between 1880 and 1900, with 993 works, 58% of the studied corpus.
- Themes by dates:
- The 422 dancers and 287 bathers executed between 1880 and 1900;
- The period from 1880 to 1900 truly marks the apex of Degas's work.
After 1900, his work slowed down and stopped around 1907, probably due to his blindness. According to our figures, works on paper dominate, with works on canvas following relatively far behind. This clearly shows Degas's fondness for this medium. We have already given the reasons.

And Tomorrow?

We hope that our work can serve other researchers. As for us, we still need to complete the files with information from art gallery account books, numerous sales catalogues, and exhibitions.

Multiple aspects of Degas's work are emerging today. Let us not doubt that this work, never done before, which marks a major step in our knowledge of Degas's work and its history, can now become the reference on this artist. The digital critical catalogue of Degas will thus contribute to advancing our knowledge of an artist who profoundly marked the history of French painting.

Degas, self-portrait 1855. Musée d'Orsay, Paris

Acknowledgments

I thank all those who helped and encouraged me:

Jean-François Desclaux whose help and patience were crucial for the success of the first version of this site
Louise d'Argencourt, Paris
Caroline Balcon (Drouot Archives)
Armelle Baron, Paris (L'Estampille)
Olivier Berman, Paris (Artcurial)
Jacqueline Bertin Edelheit, Paris
Gérard Bouté, Baden
Guy Boyer, Paris (Connaissance des Arts)
Laurence des Cars, Paris (former president of the Musée d'Orsay and Orangerie)
Thomas Colville, Connecticut
Chris Dercon, Paris (former president of the Réunion des Musées Nationaux)
David Dupont, Geneva
Emmanuel Duprat, Milan
Flavie Durand-Ruel, Paris
Danielle Escher, Paris
Galerie de Bayser, Paris
Gloria Groom, The Art Institute of Chicago
Vivien Hamilton, Glasgow (former Burrell Collection)
Sylvie Harburger, Paris
Helly Nahmad Gallery, New York
David Jarmai, London
Gary Kraut, Paris (France Revisited website)
Dominique Lancastre, Paris (Pluton Magazine)
Pascale Leprince-Ringuet, Paris (journalist)
Georges Levet, Paris
David Lévy (Galerie Paris-Bruxelles)
Dominique Lobstein, Paris
Marie-Christine Maufus (former Wildenstein Institute)
Bruce Mee, Paris (Lawyer)
Thierry Mercier, Paris (former Galerie Mercier)
Patrick Minot, Boissise-le-Roi
Jill Newhouse, New York (Galerie Jill New House)
Agnès Pénot, Los Angeles
Jean Penicaut, Paris
Roberto Perazzone and Irénée Brun, Paris (Expert firm)
Annie Pfeffer, Strasbourg
Sophie Piétri, Paris (former Wildenstein Institute)
Alain Prévet, former researcher on spoliated assets at the Ministry of Culture (M2RS)
Galerie Paul Prouté, Paris
Diane de Puységur, Paris
Theodore Reff, New York
Jeanne Rigal, Paris (Christie's)
Jane Roberts, Paris
Marianne Rosenberg, New York (Galerie Rosenberg)
Elisabeth Royer, Paris
Elisabeth Santacreu, Paris (Le Journal des Arts)
Schiller and Bodo, New York (former New York gallery)
Michaël Sfez, Paris
Eric Turquin, Paris (Cabinet Eric Turquin)
Bénédicte Van Campen, Paris
Guy Wildenstein, Paris (former Wildenstein Institute)

I thank all the museums that graciously granted me the right to publish their photo(s). I also thank the libraries and research centers that welcomed and helped me:

National Archives, Paris
Picasso Museum Library, Paris
Petit Palais Library, Paris
Bibliothèque nationale de France, Paris
Frick Art Reference Library, New York
National Institute of Art History, Paris
The documentation and library of the Musée d'Orsay
The Getty Art Research Institute, Los Angeles
The Morgan Library and Museum, New York