Seated woman - Study for woman seated beside a vase of flowers

Atelier Degas - Vente Degas, 1918, I, n° 312 (repr.) - Paul Rosenberg, Paris - Paul J. Sachs, 1927 - Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, 1965  [Don Sachs].

Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, 1929, French Painting of the 19th & 20th Centuries, n° 34, repr. p.  25 – New York, Jacques Seligmann & Co., 1930,  Exhibition of Drawings by Degas,  n° 19 – Saint-Louis, City Art Museum, 1932, Drawings by Degas  – Pittsburgh, Junior League, 1933-1934,  An Exhibition of Old-Master Drawings for the Benefit of Public Health Nursing Milk and Emergency Fund, n° 31  – Boston, Boston Museum of Fine Arts, 1935, Independent Painters of 19th Century Paris, n° 120  – Philadelphie, Pennsylvania Museum of Art, 1936, Degas, n° 39 (repr.)  – Paris, musée de l’Orangerie, 1937, Degas, n° 73 - Brooklyn, Institute of Arts and Sciences, 1939, Great Modern French, n° 11 (repr. en couv.)  – Washington, Phillips Memorial Gallery, 1940,  Great Modern Drawings – Detroit, Detroit Institute of Arts, 1941, Masterpieces of 19th and 20th Century French Drawing from the Fogg Museum of Art at Harvard University and the Museum of Modern Art of New York City, n° 20 – New York, Buchholz Gallery, 1945, Edgar Degas Bronzes, Drawings, n° 58 – Farnsworth Art Museum, Wellesley College, 1946, Drawings by Degas – Cleveland, Cleveland Museum of Art, 1947, Works by Edgar Degas, n° 62 (repr.)  – Washington, Phillips Memorial Gallery, 1947, Loan Exhibition of Drawings & Pastels by Edgar Degas, n° 31 – New York, Century Club, 1947, Drawings from the Fogg Museum of Art, Harvard University (Collection Paul J. Sachs) – Minneapolis, Institute of Arts, 1948,  Drawings from the Fogg Museum of Art, Harvard University (Collection  Paul J. Sachs), n°  10  – Philadelphie, Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1950-1951, The Diamond Jubilee -  Richmond, Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, 1952, French Drawings from the Fogg Art Museum -  Paris, musée de l’Orangerie, 1955,  De David à Toulouse-Lautrec : chefs d'oeuvre des collections américaines, n° 69 – San Antonio,  The Marion Koogler McNay Art Museum, 1955, Paintings, Drawings, Prints and Sculpture by Edgar Degas – Waterville, Colby College, 1956, An Exhibition of Drawings,  n° 68  – Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, 1961, Ingres and Degas: Two Classical Draughtsmen,  n° 8  – Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, New York, The Museum of Modern Art, 1965-1967,  Memorial Exhibition : Works of Art from the Collection of Paul J. Sachs [1878-1965] Given and Bequeathed to the Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University, Cambridge, n° 74 (repr.)  – New Haven, Yale University Art Gallery, 1987,  Paintings, Drawings, Sculpture from the Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University – Paris, Ottawa, New York, 1988-1989, Degas, n° 61, repr. p. 116 – Tokyo, Yamagushi, 1990, The Maurice Wertheim Collection and Selected Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Paintings and Drawings in the Fogg Art Museum – Dumas, Brenneman, Cat. exp. Atlanta, Minnepaolis, 2000-2001, Degas and America. The Early Collectors, cat. 17, repr. p. 116.

Henri Rivière, Les Dessins de Degas, 1922-1923, pl. 59 - Laura Howland Dudley, "The New Fogg Art Museum - The Collection of Prints", The Arts, juillet 1927, vol. XII, n° 1, pp. 28-32, repr. p. 32 - Exhibition of French Painting of the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries, Cat. exp. Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, 1929, n° 34 - Fogg Art Museum Handbook, Fogg Art Museum, Cambridge, 1931, p. 112, (repr.) - Louise Burroughs, "Degas in the Havemeyer Collection", The Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1932, vol. XXVII, n° 5, p. 145 - Agnes Mongan, "Portrait Studies by Degas in American Collections", Bulletin of the Fogg Art Museum, mai 1932, vol. 1, n° 4, p. 65, fig. 5 - Margaret Scott, An Exhibition of Old-Master Drawings for the Benefit of Public Health Nursing Milk and Emergency Fund, Cat. exp. Junior League, Pittsburgh, 1933, n° 31 - Independent Painters of Nineteenth Century Paris, Cat. exp. Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 1935, n° 120 - Degas, Cat. exp. Philadelphie, Pennsylvania Museum of Art, 1936, n° 69 (repr.) - Jacqueline Bouchot-Saupique, Degas, Cat. exp. Paris, musée de l'Orangerie, 1937, n° 73 - Agnes Mongan, Paul J. Sachs, Drawings in the Fogg Museum of Art, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1940, vol. 1, cat. n° 667, fig. 343 - Masterpieces of 19th and 20th Century French Drawing from the Fogg Museum... brochure, Detroit Institute of Arts 1941, checklist, n° 20 - Paul J. Sachs, "Extracts from Letters of Henri Focillon", Gazette des Beaux-Arts, juillet-décembre 1944, vol. XXVI, pp. 11-12, repr. fig. 1 - Margaret Breuning, "Master Drawings at Century Club", Art Digest, 1 juin 1947, vol. 21, n° 17, repr. p. 16 - Hans Tietze, European Master Drawings in the United States, 1947, n° 144, (repr.) - Washington, Phillips Memorial Gallery, Loan exhibition of Drawings & Pastels by Edgar Degas, Cat. exp. Washington, Phillips Memorial Gallery, 1947, n° 31 - Works by Edgar Degas, Cat. exp. Cleveland, Cleveland Museum of Art, 1947, n° 62, pl. XLIX - Edgar Degas Letters, Marcel Guérin, Bruno Cassirer, Oxford, 1948, repr. 8 (Mme Hertel) - Diamond Jubilee Exhibition :Masterpieces of Drawing, Cat. exp. Philadelphie, Philadelphia Museum of Art, 1950, n° 94, (repr.) - Regina Shoolman, Charles E. Slatkin, Six Centuries of French Master Drawings in America, 1950, p. 182, pl. 103 - Daniel Catton Rich, Edgar Degas, 1951, pl. 6 - Paul J. Sachs, The Pocket Book of Great Drawings, 1951, pp. 105-106, pl. 63 - De David à Toulouse-Lautrec : chefs-d'oeuvre des collections américaines, Cat. exp. Paris, musée de l'Orangerie, 1955, n° 69, pl. 53 - Yujiro Shinoda, "Degas : der Einzug des Japanischen in die französische Malerei" (Thèse, Université de Cologne, 1957, p. 19, fig. 3 - Jakob Rosenberg, Great Draughtsmen from Pisanello to Picasso, Cambridge, 1959, p. 109, fig. 202 - The Nature of Drawing, British Broadcasting Corporation, Londres, 1959, fig. 29 - Ingres and Degas : Two Classical Draughtsmen, Cat. exp. Cambridge, Fogg Art Museum, 1961, n° 8 - Jaromir Pecirka, Edgar Degas : Drawings, 1963, pl. 7 - Agnes Mongan, Memorial Exhibition: Works of Art from the Collection of Paul J. Sachs [1878-1965]  Given and Bequeathed to the Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University, Cambridge, 1965, n°  57 (repr.) - Paintings, Drawings, and Sculpture from the Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University, Cat. exp. Yale University Art Gallery, New Haven, 1967 - Gordon C. Aymar, The Art of Portrait Painting, 1967, pp. 140 et 144  - Jean Leymarie, Dessins de la période impressionniste de Manet à Renoir, 1969, p. 43, repr. pp. 44 et 13 - Norman Laliberté, Alex Mogelon, Drawing with Pencils. History and Modern Techniques, 1970, repr. p. 8 (Portrait de Mme Hertel) - Degas' Drawings, 1973, repr. en couv. et pl. 21 - Jakob Rosenberg, Great Draughtsmen from Pisanello to Picasso [Nouvelle édition.], 1974, p. 147, fig. 266 - Impressionism : A Centenary Exhibition, Cat. exp. New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1974, p. 73, n° 10 - Theodore Reff, Degas : The Artist's Mind [Réedition], The Metropolitan Museum of Art , 1976, pp. 48-49, fig. 24 - Theodore Reff, "Degas : A Master Among Masters", The Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1977, vol. XXXIV, n° 4, fig. 7 - Eduard Hüttinger, Degas, 1977, repr. p. 8 [Etude pour Portrait of Mme Hertel] - Ian Dunlop, Degas, 1979, fig. 59 - Denys Sutton, Edgar Degas, Life and Work, 1986, p. 67 - Richard Kendall, Degas by himself : Drawings, Prints, Paintings, Writings, 1987, pl. 64 (en coul.) [Etude pour Mme Hertel] - Theodore Reff, Degas : The Artist's Mind, 1987, pp. 48-49, fig. 24 - Jean Sutherland Boggs, Degas, Cat. exp, Paris, Ottawa, New York, 1988-1989, Degas, n° 61 (repr.) - Denis Rouart, Degas in Search of His Technique, 1988, repr. p. 122 - Horst Keller, Edgar Degas, 1988, fig. 27 - The Maurice Wertheim Collection and Selected Impressionist and Post-Impressionist Paintings and Drawings in the Fogg Art Museum, Cat. exp. 1990, n° 46 (repr.) - Bernd Growe, Edgar Degas, 1991, repr. p. 17 - Ann Dumas, Colta Ives, The Private Collection of Edgar Degas, Cat. exp. New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1997, p. 144, fig. 184 - Dumas, Brenneman, Cat. exp. Atlanta, Minneapolis, 2000-2001, Degas and America. The Early Collectors, cat. 17, repr. p. 116 - Christopher Reed, "Mad for Degas", Harvard Magazine, juillet-août 2005, vol. 107, n° 6, pp. 40-45, repr. p. 43 - Cohn, Boggs, Degas at Harvard, Cat. exp. Harvard University Art Museums/Yale University Press, Cambridge et New Haven, 2005, n° 38, fig. 5, repr. p. 22 - DeVonyar,  Kendall, Degas and the Art of Japan, Cat. exp. Reading Museum / Yale University Press, 2007, p. 15, repr. fig. 7 - Louis-Antoine Prat, Le dessin français au XIXe siècle, 2011, p. 527, repr. p. 526, fig. 1268.